At the YAF Freedom Conference in San Diego, California, Michael Knowles delivered a speech titled “‘Ordo Amoris’: The Hierarchy of Political Love.” Knowles touched on the topic of immigration, highlighting the recent changes in border policies and the historical context of deportations in the United States.
Knowles emphasized that deportations have been a longstanding practice in American history, citing various instances such as Indian Removal in 1830, the Palmer Raids in 1919 and 1920, and Operation Wetback in 1954. He argued that while opinions may vary on the necessity of these deportations, they are undeniably American traditions.
Turning to the moral and religious aspects of deportation, Knowles referenced biblical passages that address the treatment of foreigners. He pointed out that while scripture calls for care and justice towards foreigners, it also emphasizes the importance of upholding the law without favoritism. Knowles argued that the enforcement of laws is not oppressive but rather essential in ensuring justice for all individuals, regardless of their background.
The speech then delved into a debate sparked by Vice President JD Vance’s comments on prioritizing love and care starting from one’s family and extending outward. This led to a discussion on the concept of “ordo amoris,” or the order of love, as articulated by Saint Thomas Aquinas. The idea of prioritizing responsibilities based on relationships resonated with some and sparked disagreement with others, including a Yale professor who challenged the theological origins of the concept.
Knowles concluded by highlighting the significance of understanding the balance between hospitality towards foreigners and the enforcement of justice for all individuals. The speech provided a thought-provoking perspective on the complexities of immigration policies and the moral considerations surrounding them.