The online right is at a turning point, facing challenges and identity issues as political dynamics shift. From 2015 to 2025, this group thrived on the internet, creating new ideas and memes, and influencing significant political events, including Donald Trump’s victories. However, with Trump now in power and Elon Musk’s changes to Twitter, the landscape has altered dramatically. The online right can no longer push boundaries in the same way, leading to confusion and a struggle for relevance.
Many influential figures in this space are grappling with their roles. The excitement of being outsiders has faded as they now confront the reality of being part of a political administration. The online right’s strength came from being oppositional, but with Trump acting on many of their ideas, their words carry less weight. The challenge is for these figures to adapt from critics to effective institutional players, which is a difficult leap for many.
There’s also a growing sense of entitlement and resentment among some factions of the right. Online platforms reward extreme views, leading to conspiracies and divisive narratives that attract attention but don’t translate well to electoral success. For instance, while some figures gain fame through outrageous claims, successful political ideas tend to be more straightforward and inclusive.
The disconnect between online rhetoric and the actual voter base is evident. Some groups within the right have adopted a style of grievance politics that doesn’t resonate with the broader coalition that supported Trump. His success came not just from white working-class support but also from increasing votes among Latino and Asian communities. This highlights the need for a forward-looking approach that builds bridges rather than divides.
In higher education, the current administration has taken significant steps to reform the system, dismantling funding for organizations perceived as radical and targeting universities for their policies. The focus has been on promoting colorblind equality and free speech, which are popular among many voters. The administration is encouraged to continue these reforms, ensuring that all students are protected and that educational institutions adhere to standards of fairness.
Looking ahead, the right faces a crucial question: how to build effective institutions. Options include reforming existing ones, dismantling those that can’t be fixed, or creating new entities. While tearing down institutions can be straightforward, the real challenge lies in reforming and building them. This requires a blend of skills that the right must develop, as current personalities often fall short.
The right needs a new type of leader—someone who can engage in political conflict while also building and maintaining institutions. This long-term project requires commitment and resources, but it is essential for the future of the movement. As the political landscape evolves, the right must adapt to ensure its relevance and effectiveness in the years to come.