As the cardinals of the Catholic Church gather in the Sistine Chapel to elect a new pope, a controversy has arisen over remarks made by Canadian Cardinal Michael Czerny. In an interview with the New York Times, Czerny expressed discomfort regarding some African cardinals, stating, “I can think of some African cardinals — they make me shudder.” This comment has sparked discussions about racism and bias within the Church.
Czerny’s remarks came as the Church prepares for a conclave with a significant number of African cardinals participating. There are 17 cardinal electors from Africa this time, an increase from 11 in 2013. Despite this growth, African cardinals still represent only 12% of the total electors, which is less than their 19% share of the global Catholic population.
The New York Times further questioned Czerny about whether conservative cardinals were supporting an African pope as a means to push their agenda. Czerny seemed to agree, calling it “stupid” to suggest that “Africa’s time has come.” He later clarified in an interview with America magazine that he believes the focus should be on the qualities of the next pope rather than geographical representation.
Czerny has been vocal in the media leading up to the conclave, often criticizing calls for unity as a cover for reversing the reforms of Pope Francis. His comments about African cardinals have raised eyebrows, especially as they prepare to play a more prominent role in the election of the new pope.
The portrayal of African cardinals as pawns of conservative Western cardinals is misleading. Potential candidates from Africa have diverse views and priorities. For instance, Cardinal Peter Turkson emphasizes social justice, while Cardinal Fridolin Ambongo Besungu advocates for environmental issues and peace, despite his conservative stance on same-sex blessings.
Czerny’s comments could alienate African cardinals, who may be less inclined to support his views. Some observers suggest that his remarks might even strengthen the resolve of those favoring candidates like Cardinal Ambongo Besungu, who has a significant following among African Catholics.
In light of these tensions, prominent figures like Father James Martin have spoken out against what they see as harmful rhetoric within the Church. As the conclave approaches, the dynamics among the cardinals are more complex than ever, with the potential for significant changes in the leadership of the Catholic Church hanging in the balance.