The revival of "Floyd Collins" is captivating audiences at the Vivian Beaumont Theater in New York City. This musical tells the true story of Floyd Collins, a spelunker who became trapped in a cave in Kentucky in 1925. The show runs for two hours and 35 minutes, including an intermission, and features a powerful performance by Jeremy Jordan in the lead role.
The story unfolds in two contrasting settings: the dark, cold cave where Floyd is trapped and the bustling town above, which becomes a spectacle as news of his plight spreads. The townspeople, portrayed as opportunistic characters, capitalize on his misfortune, creating a striking contrast between Floyd’s struggle underground and the chaos above.
The musical features a score by Adam Guettel that combines haunting melodies with moments of unexpected beauty. Guettel’s music has been compared to the cinematic works of Ennio Morricone, infusing the dark cave with a sense of romance and allure. As Floyd’s situation worsens, the music shifts from uplifting to somber, reflecting his dire circumstances.
Despite the musical’s strong score, the book by writer-director Tina Landau has received mixed reviews. Critics argue that the characters often feel like stereotypes rather than fully developed individuals. This lack of depth in the script detracts from the emotional impact of the story, leaving audiences feeling disconnected from the characters’ struggles.
Supporting characters like Floyd’s sister, Nellie, and their father, Lee, played by Lizzy McAlpine and Marc Kudisch, respectively, struggle to find their voices in the narrative. Their songs lack the dramatic weight needed to resonate with the audience. However, characters like the eager reporter Skeets Miller, portrayed by Taylor Trensch, and Floyd’s brother Homer, played by Jason Gotay, bring a sense of humanity and connection to the story.
Director Tina Landau’s staging is visually striking, making the most of the theater’s large space. However, some critics feel that the dialogue could be improved to better match the quality of the music. The production captures the essence of the 1920s, but the characters sometimes come across as one-dimensional.
Overall, "Floyd Collins" is a musical that showcases stunning music and powerful performances, particularly from Jeremy Jordan. While it has its flaws, the revival at Lincoln Center offers a compelling glimpse into a tragic yet fascinating piece of American history. Whether audiences will connect with the characters remains to be seen, but the music alone makes it worth experiencing.