Matt Walsh, a popular podcaster and documentarian, has stirred up quite a conversation with his strong dislike for "Star Wars." His disdain became clear during a May 2023 episode of his show when he reacted negatively to a guest who mentioned playing a new "Star Wars" game. Walsh called the guest a "complete and utter disgrace," showcasing his intense feelings about the franchise.
Recently, theaters across the country celebrated the 20th anniversary of "Star Wars: Episode III – Revenge of the Sith" with a week-long re-release. This film is often praised for its stunning visuals, memorable music, and important themes. However, Walsh took his children to see the film and subsequently criticized it on social media.
One of his main complaints was about the film’s dialogue. He claimed it featured the worst lines he had ever heard in a Hollywood movie, citing a romantic exchange between Anakin Skywalker and Padmé Amidala. Critics of Walsh argue that he misinterpreted the scene, which serves as foreshadowing for Anakin’s tragic choices later in the story.
Walsh also slammed the action choreography, particularly the climactic duel between Anakin and Obi-Wan Kenobi. He described it as absurd, questioning the logic behind Anakin’s final move in the fight. However, many fans and critics regard this battle as one of the greatest in cinema history, with expert choreography and intense training by the actors.
In his critique, Walsh expressed confusion over the film’s setting on Mustafar, a lava planet. He seemed unaware of its significance in "Star Wars" lore, where it is depicted as a location that enhances the Dark Side of the Force. This setting plays a crucial role in Anakin’s transformation into Darth Vader.
Walsh concluded his criticisms by stating that the film took itself too seriously, arguing that it was inappropriate to mix lighthearted moments with dark themes like child slaughter. However, many fans believe that the film’s blend of tones is intentional, reflecting the tragic arc of Anakin’s character over the course of the series.
Despite his criticisms, Walsh noted that his children enjoyed the movie. This sentiment resonates with many fans who see "Revenge of the Sith" as a significant part of the "Star Wars" saga. As the anniversary celebration continues, some hope that Walsh might reconsider his views and watch the film again with a fresh perspective.