The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has taken a significant step by issuing administrative subpoenas to Harvard University. This action demands that the prestigious institution provide information about its foreign students. The DHS claims that Harvard has repeatedly ignored requests to share necessary details for its Student Visitor and Exchange Program certification.
The dispute stems from allegations that Harvard has not been forthcoming with information related to immigration law enforcement on its campus. The DHS is particularly interested in records dating back to January 1, 2020, due to claims of unequal treatment of nonimmigrant students. Tricia McLaughlin, the DHS Assistant Secretary, stated, “We tried to do things the easy way with Harvard. Now, through their refusal to cooperate, we have to do things the hard way.” She accused Harvard of allowing foreign students to misuse their visa privileges and promote violence.
This conflict is part of a larger ongoing tension between the Trump administration and Harvard regarding international students. Recently, President Trump attempted to halt the enrollment of foreign students at Harvard, where they make up 27% of the student body for the 2024-2025 academic year. In May, Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem ordered the termination of Harvard’s certification for its Student and Exchange Visitor Program. She criticized Harvard for not complying with federal requirements.
The DHS also expressed concern about antisemitism and foreign influence at Harvard, claiming the university has not adequately addressed these issues. Trump has previously mentioned that Harvard’s refusal to provide data on misconduct among foreign students poses an “unacceptable risk.” Additionally, the administration has cut more than $2 billion in federal funding for Harvard, citing its diversity initiatives and failure to confront antisemitism.
Despite the ongoing tensions, there seemed to be a potential thaw in relations recently. Trump hinted at a possible “historic” deal with Harvard, suggesting that negotiations were in progress. However, as of now, no agreement has been finalized.
This situation highlights the challenges universities face in balancing compliance with federal regulations and maintaining their academic missions. The outcome of this dispute could have significant implications for Harvard and other institutions dealing with similar requests from the government.